The Supreme Court ruled that allegations that the administration’s memorandum to exclude illegal immigrants from the census creates a “substantial risk” of “reduced representation and federal resources” is based on “significant” guesswork. Judge Lucy H. Koh, of the U.S. District Court in the Northern District of California, ordered the bureau to keep working through the Oct. 31 deadline. The administration had asked the high court for "immediate relief" because a lower court order would have required the census count to continue until October 31. On Saturday, Mr. Wall wrote that as of Oct. 9 the bureau had counted over 99 percent of households in 49 states. Justice Sonia Sotomayor dissented, saying that “the harms associated with an inaccurate census are avoidable and intolerable.”. CNN's Paul LeBlanc contributed to this report. The Supreme Court ruling came in response to a lawsuit by a coalition of local governments and civil rights groups, arguing that minorities and others in hard-to-count … Ditas Katague, who has led a nearly $200 million campaign by California to encourage a complete tally, said the decision “could have grave consequences for the next decade” and said the state would continue to fight in court for fair representation during the apportionment of House seats. Attorneys for the groups that sued the administration told CNN they will wait to see the Census Bureau's next steps to determine how to respond. The Supreme Court on Friday, by a vote of 6-3, said an effort to block President Trump from excluding undocumented immigrants from a key Census count was "premature." For the same reason, Mr. Trump’s plan to exclude unauthorized immigrants from population totals used to allot political power would probably further dilute Democratic representation in many — though hardly all — areas with large immigrant populations. The administration said last week … But such a move would be difficult, Carl Tobias, a law professor at the University of Richmond, told CNN. Because those groups live predominantly in urban areas, an undercount also would be likely to dilute the political power of Democrats who disproportionately represent those areas. President Trump has insisted those numbers should not include undocumented immigrants living in the United States. WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Tuesday allowed the Trump administration to halt the 2020 census count ahead of schedule, effectively shutting down what has been the most contentious and litigated census in memory and setting the stage for a bitter fight over how to use its numbers for the apportionment of the next Congress. Supreme Court puts off ruling on Census count that excludes illegal immigrants In this Nov. 5, 2020 The census determines how many representatives each state gets in Congress and how billions of dollars in federal funding is spent. Supreme Court grants Trump administration request to end census count. Supreme Court rules it's too early to review Trump census plan to exclude undocumented immigrants from House redistricting By Camilo Montoya-Galvez Updated on: December 18, 2020 / … In fact, some census workers say, the bureau had already begun shutting down some parts of its count despite a court order to continue it. But that was widely questioned by census and demographic experts, who cast the number as a public relations estimate that concealed broad gaps in the accuracy of the tally. Supreme Court rules in Trump’s favor to end US Census count early The justices on Tuesday stopped the once-a-decade head count of every U.S. resident from continuing through the end of … The National Urban League, the League of Women Voters, other groups and local governments sued, saying the rushed schedule would undermine the accuracy of the census and “facilitate another illegal act: suppressing the political power of communities of color by excluding undocumented people from the final apportionment count.”. In late July and early August, Ross directed Census officials to come up with a plan to condense the door knocking operation, shorten the number-crunching process and meet the December 31 deadline. The court’s ruling is the latest turn in a roller coaster of a legal fight over the timeline for the count. The Supreme Court on Tuesday allowed the Trump administration to immediately stop counting people for the 2020 census rather than continue counting through the end of the month as a lower court had ordered. “The commerce secretary’s next steps will tell us everything we need to know.”. By Ariane de Vogue and Gregory Wallace, CNN, Updated 0218 GMT (1018 HKT) October 14, 2020. And while this year's census has relied more heavily on collecting responses by phone, mail or online, the operation still needs a robust field operation to reach minority communities as well as students on college campuses, seniors in assisted living facilities and people experiencing homelessness. The two developments appear related. Because of that delay, the Census Bureau said it would move the dates for delivering population figures used by the House and states for reapportionment and redistricting to next April and beyond. It forced the bureau to abandon on short notice some of the counting safeguards it was using to make the tally reliable. At issue in … That conflicts with the mandate of the Constitution that the census count all residents of the country and would almost certainly give more representation to Republicans. Most experts said a shortened census would only worsen existing undercounts of the people who have always been hardest for census workers to reach — minorities who are suspicious of the government, and the poor and young people, who move frequently and are more difficult to track down. Wall, the acting solicitor general, told the justices in a brief filed on Wednesday. That suggested a concern that Republican leadership, rather than a potential Joe Biden presidency, make determinations over who is counted, while also risking a significant undercount of the population in as many as 10 states. A federal judge had ordered the Census Bureau to continue enumeration until Oct. 31. The brief unsigned order formally only pauses the population count while the administration and a host of groups advocating a more accurate census battle in a federal appeals court over whether the count could be stopped early. The Supreme Court ruled Tuesday the U.S. Census Bureau can conclude its 2020 count early, giving it enough time to finish with enough time to … Supreme Court allows Trump administration to end census count. “The Supreme Court’s decision today to allow the Census Bureau to stop counting households before the end of October is truly disappointing, particularly since it simply ignores the clear legal points in Justice Sotomayor’s dissent. Critics saw a political motive. After extending the deadline to count every person in America, a process complicated by the coronavirus pandemic, the Trump administration reversed course. The court’s order gave no reasons, which is typical when the court acts on emergency applications. But the panel said it would not bar the administration from trying to comply with the Dec. 31 reporting deadline. The director of New York City’s efforts to increase census turnout, Julie Menin, said the count had “been stolen by the Trump administration, which has interfered at every step of the way.”. While the order formally only pauses the census, it likely ensures an early end. The Court approved an emergency request from the Justice Department to suspend a lower court decision that extended the Census count through the end of the month. The Supreme Court’s decision on Tuesday effectively halted what has been the most contentious and litigated census count in memory. The census has been buffeted both by the coronavirus pandemic and the involvement of the Trump administration in what has traditionally been a rigorously nonpartisan, data-driven exercise. As a practical matter, however, it almost certainly ensures an early end because the census — one of the largest government activities, involving hundreds of thousands of workers — cannot be easily restarted and little time remains before its current deadline at the end of this month. WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court has dismissed as premature a challenge to President Donald Trump ’s plan to exclude people living in the country illegally from the population count used to allot states’ seats in the House of Representatives. “As the law stands,” Mr. Wall wrote, “assessing any trade-off between speed and accuracy is a job for Congress, which set the Dec. 31 deadline and has not extended it, and the agencies, which acted reasonably in complying with that deadline.”. The U.S. Supreme Court ducked a direct ruling Friday on whether President Trump can exclude undocumented immigrants from a key census count. The Supreme Court has dismissed as premature a challenge to President Donald Trump's plan to exclude people living in the country illegally from the population count used to allot states seats in the House of Representatives. "Every day has mattered, and the Supreme Court's order staying the preliminary injunction does not erase the tremendous progress that has been made as a result of the district court's rulings," Melissa Arbus Sherry, an attorney at Latham and Watkins who argued the case in the trial court, said in a statement. Schools, roads and other important things in communities will gain -- or lose -- funding over the next 10 years depending on this official population tally. "This stay is effectively the end of it," he said. Updated 10:18 PM ET, Tue October 13, 2020 (CNN) The Supreme Court on Tuesday granted a request from the Trump administration to halt the census count while an appeal plays out over a … Supreme Court Rules That Census Count Can Be Cut Short. Legal. The order was a major victory for the Trump administration, which had been rebuffed by both district and appeals courts in its effort to end the count early. The Supreme Court ruled in favor of President Donald Trump Tuesday and allowed the administration to cut the count early, before its original Oct. 31 end date. In one email, Ross asked if a shortened schedule would allow the numbers to be produced during Trump's presidency. The US Supreme Court set aside a 9th circuit court order that extended counting efforts for the 2020 census through October 31, allowing the Trump administration to end counting soon. “The court’s action will cause irreversible damage to efforts to achieve a fair and accurate census,” said Kristen Clarke, the president of the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, which represents many of the parties that sued. But the subtext has always been whether a curtailed count would be accurate enough to set the baseline for allotting political power and trillions of dollars over the next decade — and whether Mr. Trump was seeking to take control of the count for political advantage. The move came not long after the announcement in July that the administration would seek to exclude undocumented immigrants from the population totals it would send to Congress for reapportioning seats in the House. It said the count could stop while appeals moved forward. The Trump administration argued that would have prevented Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross from delivering a count of the nation's population to President Donald Trump by December 31. Tuesday's order is just the latest twist in what's become a long-running political dispute and is likely to, The Trump administration has exerted unprecedented political influence over the survey in ways that critics say will advantage Republicans in upcoming elections, including by rushing the process and seeking to exclude. The legal battle has focused on whether the Commerce Department, which oversees the Census Bureau, had followed federal law when it set the Sept. 30 deadline. Census workers planning routes in New York in March. The Court approved an emergency request from the Justice Department to suspend a lower court decision that extended the Census count through the end of the month. (CNN)The Supreme Court on Tuesday granted a request from the Trump administration to halt the census count while an appeal plays out over a lower court's order that it continue. Readopting the December deadline would ensure that Mr. Trump controls that process, even if he loses the November election. Its early end could mean that White House officials, rather than Census Bureau experts, may use the population numbers to determine representation in the House of Representatives and in state and local governments. Cary Coglianese, a University of Pennsylvania professor who is one of the country’s top experts on administrative law, said the ruling was in some ways unsurprising. The ruling is a win for the administration, which argued the shortened deadline is necessary to give the Commerce Department enough time to meet the December deadline. And it quickly triggered a lawsuit seeking to keep the tally going. A Supreme Court order on Tuesday was a victory for the Trump administration, which argued that it needed to shut down census field work to meet a statutory deadline. “Whatever one makes of the policy impacts underlying the Trump administration’s position on the timetable for finishing the census,” he said, “today’s ruling does generally fit with the court’s longstanding deferential posture” toward actions by federal agencies. Lawyers for the plaintiffs in the lawsuit said they would turn to making sure that the Census Bureau was not forced to make further cuts in accuracy checks during the monthslong period in which population data is processed and verified. The Trump administration can end counting for the 2020 census early after the Supreme Court approved a request to suspend a lower court order that extended the count's schedule. While the court’s ruling effectively stops the census, it does not end the legal battle over it. Mr. Ross’s action came over the objection of career census experts who argued that it would undermine, perhaps fatally, the accuracy of the count. It was a bitter defeat for state and local governments and advocacy groups that had sued to keep the population count going despite the administration’s determination to shut it down. The agency suspended field operations for a time, although that work eventually resumed in some areas. By: Kunjan Jogdand On Tuesday, the Supreme Court approved a motion from the Trump administration to suspend the count of census until an appeal continues against the decision of the lower court to continue.The administration sought Last-minute changes by the Census Bureau and its skirting of an earlier court order for the count have left local communities and the bureau’s workers across the U.S. unsure of how much longer they can take part in a national head count already upended by the coronavirus pandemic. As a result, the New York Immigration Coalition (NYIC) said the court’s decision could mean that all counting efforts and outreach will end in the next few days. Christian Monterrosa for The New York Times, should not include undocumented immigrants living in the United States, Mr. Trump’s plan to exclude unauthorized immigrants from population totals. ET. Justice Sonia Sotomayor dissented from the order, fearing that the shortened timeline would produce inaccurate results. The old deadlines would have allowed the winner of the presidential election to transmit the population totals next spring. “The district court’s order constitutes an unprecedented intrusion into the executive’s ability to conduct the census according to Congress’s direction,” Jeffrey B. "Because the harms associated with an inaccurate census are avoidable and intolerable, I respectfully dissent from the grant of stay," she wrote. The deadline for completing the count was originally moved from August to Oct. 31 after the pandemic all but shuttered many census operations last spring. A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, in San Francisco, turned down a request from the Trump administration to stay Judge Koh’s order and allow it to stop counting before the end of the month. But in August, Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross ordered the Oct. 31 deadline moved up a month to Sept. 30, saying the extra time was needed to deliver preliminary population totals to Mr. Trump by the statutory deadline of Dec. 31. The administration asked the Supreme Court to intervene, saying that only by shutting down field work now could the bureau meet the Dec. 31 deadline, which is set by statute. “It’s incredibly disappointing.”, Terri Ann Lowenthal, a longtime census expert and consultant to several groups pressing for an accurate tally, charged that the disarray caused by the administration’s handling of the count “inevitably will undermine whatever public confidence remains in the census results.”, The administration “could do the right thing, and allow those operations to wind down in an organized way over the next two weeks, or it could continue to push for rushed results, accuracy and quality be damned,” she said. Governments with huge financial and political stakes in a full count of their jurisdictions were especially critical of the court’s ruling. The court’s decision Friday is not a final ruling … The U.S. Supreme Court dodged a ruling on whether President Trump can exclude undocumented immigrants from a key census count. The U.S. Supreme Court on Tuesday sided with the Trump administration to not extend the census count instead of allowing it to continue through the … The justices’ decision is but the latest turnabout in a saga that has seen the deadline for completing the population count — originally set for August, after a decade of preparation — shifted to Oct. 31, then abruptly changed to Sept. 30, then restored by courts to Oct. 31. The Census Bureau said the count will end on Friday at 6 a.m. The Supreme Court on Tuesday effectively allowed the government to stop the census count immediately, blocking a lower court order that would have required the Trump administration to … She also suspended the Dec. 31 statutory deadline for submitting the results. Not only are these groups at high risk for coronavirus infection, they're also among those most in need of in-person outreach. The Supreme Court ruled in favor of President Donald Trump Tuesday and allowed the administration to cut the count early, before its original Oct. 31 end date. Supreme Court rules challenge to Trump census plan to exclude undocumented immigrants is premature.
Lisa Brown Illustrator, Roger Staubach Stats, Kathryn Morris Johnny Messner, Killing Eve Where To Watch, Top Gear: Us Special, Ripley Under Ground,